Alright guys, you know I love trying new things, so when the opportunity arose to try 3 Plated meals for free, I just HAD to jump on it (YAY FREE FOOD!)!
If you can remember, I tried out Blue Apron this past December (you can read my review of it here) and wasn’t the biggest fan, so I was a bit pessimistic to give another one of these meal delivery services a shot, but when there’s an offer for free food, one does not turn it down.
If you are considering trying Plated, please continue reading for my detailed review below!
INITIAL SIGN-UP
Overall, sign up for Plated was pretty easy and took me about 5 minutes to complete. I simply selected the correct meal plan that I was gifted (3 meals with 2 servings each; normally $108 per week) and continued on to my delivery date preferences. From there, I was taken to a screen that allowed me to change my meals. This was an AWESOME feature because when I did Blue Apron I got stuck with the meals that were featured that week (either I didn’t follow directions and overlooked the section to change the meals, or you really are stuck with what you’re given). But here, I could swap out all 3 recipes if I wanted with the 12 total recipes being featured that week. I changed 2 out of the 3 recipes for meals that were more my taste, so I truly appreciated the opportunity to swap meals. Overall, there was a nice mix of chicken, steak, pork, and pasta dishes, so I would give them a gold-star sticker for their variety.
And of course, like all the other meal delivery plans you always have the ability to skip weeks or cancel the subscription, but be sure to do so by your weekly deadline to avoid being charged.
COST
I will be honest and say that the cost of these services really turn me off. I personally try to keep the cost per serving of my typical dinner meals around $3-4 (so usually $12 or less for a dinner with 4 servings). The Plated meal plans run at $12 per serving..yes, you read that right, per serving. So one serving of their meals is the equivalent of my entire dinner for my family. Call me cheap, but that’s not realistic for a lot of folks I know.
The meal plans are advertised as being quick and convenient–which is essentially what you are “paying for” by avoiding the hassle of meal planning and grocery shopping. But, like all things in life, one must ask themselves if the price is truly worth it.
Here’s a screen shot of how much the 3 meals per week would cost you for 2 servings each. Note, new members get one of the meals free the first week, but regular prices are listed above and crossed out.

FOOD ARRIVAL
I got home from work to find the big box sitting on my porch. The box was made of recycled ingredients which was ecofriendly (a plus in my book) and was equipped with 2 huge ice-coolers to keep my food fresh.
The food was neatly packaged and organized per recipe, which was a huge plus because Blue Apron just threw all the produce together and you had to kind of sort through what was going to be used for what. But with Plated, all the ingredients for each recipe came in the same bag (with the exception of the meat), which eliminated an extra sorting step. I just simply threw all the ingredients in the fridge and was good to go in a matter of minutes.
MEAL PREP
Meal #1: Chicken Parmesan with Roasted Cauliflower

This meal was fairly easy to make. I started by preheating the oven and tossing the cauliflower and cappers in olive oil before popping them in the oven. While those roasted, I followed the instructions to bread the chicken and pan sear it. The sauce for this meal consisted of a can of chopped tomatoes and seasoning, and you guys, that sauce was DYNAMITE! The can on the tomatoes stated it was an imported product of Italy and I would seriously consider ordering it online to have it shipped to my house because it was THAT good!
Then, I sliced the mozzarella cheese, which mind you, came in a huge ball that was enough for 6 servings. This amount of cheese was obviously excessive, but when you make a nice chicken parmesan and are given a ball of mozzarella cheese, you use it.
Once the sauce was prepped and chicken was pan fried, it was time to throw it in a baking dish and top it with the sauce and mozzarella cheese slices. I baked the dish for about 10 minutes and voilà, my meal was complete in about 30 minutes which was pretty darn speedy for a gourmet looking dish! You will notice though that I added some whole grain spaghetti to this dish to give it some more “oomph” for the hubby. He was happy I did 🙂
The dish was beautiful and so yummy that I just HAD to tweet it out to Gordon Ramsey for his feedback. Sadly, he didn’t respond. But with or without Gordon’s approval, this dish was an Italian win in my book! My only criticism for this meal came down to the capers and cauliflower mixture. Capers are extremely salty, so I was surprised that the recipe asked me to add additional salt to the cauliflower prior to roasting. I’m glad I omitted the extra salt because I would have found it to be inedible. But capers and cauliflower? Who would have thought they would make such an awesome pair!
Meal #2: Steak Frites with Creamy Shallot Sauce

Steak and homemade fries–how can I butcher this one (no pun intended)?! Well–I managed to overcook the steak and was unable to cut it against the grain for pretty pictures, but I blame that on the thinness of the meat itself ;).
This was another relatively easy dish to make. I started by slicing the potatoes into fries (no peeling necessary), and seasoned them with some fresh ground pepper, salt, and olive oil. I popped these in the oven and moved on to the steak.
I was happy to find that the steak was high quality, grass fed beef (more omega-3s!) and not some cheap-o block of blah. I seared it in a cast-iron skillet per instructions, but I made the mistake of slightly overcooking it be well-done instead of my desired medium-rare. Gah–I just had to ruin it somehow, didn’t I? I decided to brush off my shoulders and redeem myself with the shallot sauce as the fries finished baking.
The shallot sauce was so easy to make and TO DIE FOR! I would literally pour that sauce over anything from fish, to chicken, to a salad, to a flipping dip for a cracker. In all honesty, I may or may not have licked the sauce-pan clean. It was seriously THAT GOOD!
To make the sauce, I sliced the shallots and sautéed them in some olive oil and white wine. I then added the extra ingredients that were included (horseradish, spicy mustard, sour cream, and something else that I can’t remember). 
It only took about 5 minutes to whip up and finished at the same time as the fries. The last step was to plate it, but I gave up on slicing the steak into pretty portions so my husband wouldn’t criticize my culinary skills. The end product was missing the sautéed spinach because a.) my husband was my meal guinea pig and wouldn’t eat cooked spinach and b.) I was going to make feta cheese and spinach stuffed chicken that week so it was one last thing for me to buy if I reserved the spinach for myself.
He really liked the sauce and homemade fries, so I made a point to save this recipe card because it’s an impressive, unique twist on a classical steak dish that should be made again and again! I’ll definitely be whipping this up for a summer barbeque.

Meal #3: Chicken al Forno with Salsa Verde and Parmesan Mashed Potatoes

I didn’t know what to expect with this dish. I had never made chicken al forno, but all the ingredients looked promising so I was hoping for the best. I started by dicing the potatoes so I could boil them for my mashed potatoes
. I was then instructed to sear the chicken thighs skin down in a cast iron skillet. The chicken thighs were fresh–so fresh that they actually still had some hair on them (see the pic). This was a bit of a turn off, but having worked in a Jewish long-term care facility, I was used to seeing kosher chicken with a few feathers left on.
After searing the chicken for a bit, I removed it from the skillet so I could make the sauce. Despite loving ketchup and salsa, I’ve never been a fan of tomatoes on their own (weird, I know), so I was a bit apprehensive about the tomato and wine sauce. But I did as I was told and heated the tomatoes with the wine sauce until they were soft and broken down. I then I added the chicken back to the tomato and wine sauce filled pan and baked it all together in the oven.
As the chicken cooked, I made the salsa verde, which consisted of cilantro, garlic, olive oil, red pepper flakes, salt, pepper, and a few other ingredients I can’t remember (maybe capers?).
It was easy to whip up in my little food processor, but boy was it salty! So much so that I spit it out after the first bite. I rarely salt foods so maybe it’s my sensitive taste-buds, but I just prayed that it tasted okay when topped on the chicken and mashed potato mixture.
I set the homemade salsa aside and went to town on my mashed potatoes. The potatoes were extremely easy to make; simply drain, use a masher, then add some pepper, salt, and parmesan cheese that was included. As soon as I finished the potatoes, the timer on the oven went off and it was at last time to plate my meal!
The end result of this meal far exceeded my expectations. I was amazed how the different flavors combined to make a truly extraordinary dish. The wine sauce was amazing and masked the plain old tomato flavor I dislike, and the salsa verde blended well with the dish, too. I would DEFINITELY make this one again 🙂
FINAL THOUGHTS
Pros:
- I enjoyed Plated much more than Blue Apron
- The meals were delicious and didn’t require extensive prep time
- The ingredients were neatly organized, making meal prep a breeze
- The portions were large; so 2 servings could easily be stretched to 3 or 4 servings depending on the meal
Cons:
- The price is too high for me, so if I decided to re-order it would be for a special occasion week here and there
- Since I’m a dietitian, I tend to favor meals on the lighter side. The steak dish was the lowest calorie meal at around 650 calories per serving, but the majority of these dishes came out to be about 800 calories per serving. That is twice the calorie amount I normally consume at meals; therefore, I do not consider this meal service to be diet friendly (even the low carb options were heavier in calories and fat)
- The meals still require you to have certain ingredients on hand that are not provided, such as salt, pepper, and oil
As you can see, Plated provides delicious meals that are no doubt pretty to look at. This service helps eliminate a trip to the grocery store and the hassle of figuring out what to make for dinner, but the price tag may not be worth it for some individuals. The high fat content of meals also racks up calories, so for diet conscious individuals, these dishes may be too heavy.
The decision is ultimately yours, but I have a feeling that you will truly enjoy the flavor of these meals!
Until next time,
Erin